Cycle-1 final candidate · Fable conditions closed · HDO act pending

P-PH000-AC008-GATE001Cycle 01

Confirm the remediated workscope package

Cycle 0 was RECYCLE. TK005 is complete and Consultant-accepted. Fable 5/high then reviewed the full cycle-1 package at 590d344e…, returned ACCEPT WITH CONDITIONS, and the HDO authorized the bounded mechanical closure. CHECK001 remains complete historical assurance; the next act belongs to the HDO at this same GATE001.

Gate package: PR #486 · open, unmerged
Control ledger: Issue #449
CHECK001: Complete historical assurance · not reopened
Immutable package basis: 4a1fdce2…

What actually counts as the HDO act

An explicit durable merge, recycle, or hold disposition on PR #486 and/or the #449 ledger. On approval, the merge event and merge-hash-bound #449 acceptance ledger complete the proof trail.

Checkboxes, selected cards, and generated text below are local working aids only. They do not approve, authorize, merge, close, or modify anything—and they do not imply the HDO has acted.

Journey to the gate

RECYCLE and assurance closure complete; HDO disposition is next

Cycle 0

HDO RECYCLE

Recorded

Same GATE001 retained; registry altitude, SPS placement and metadata sent to TK005.

TK005

Remediation

Complete

Canonical SPS migration, Program registry, D3 and authority cleanup.

Task review

Independent PASS

0 findings

Cycle-1 full-scope review; Consultant accepted the return.

Package

Cycle-1 candidate

Assembled

Current immutable evidence basis 4a1fdce2.

Cycle 1

Fable gate review

Closed

ACCEPT WITH CONDITIONS; six findings, one material; bounded conditions mechanically closed without a second round.

HDO decision

Pending

Durable merge, recycle, hold or kill act on PR #486 and/or #449.

Conditional

Merge + ledger

Blocked

Only after approval: exact merge and merge-hash-bound #449 ledger.

The accepted CHECK000 architecture remains the merits boundary. AC008 encodes Initiative and Feature as the only new SID-bearing workscope tiers, Epic as mutable non-authoritative grouping, Story as removed, and Initiative-rooted Timeline UIDs as explicit workscope targets.

This is re-presentation, not re-adjudication. CHECK001 remains complete. The old cycle-0 QA staging and hash are superseded presentation evidence. The Fable review is advisory gate assurance—not a new checkpoint—and its bounded closure does not perform the HDO act.

Effect of approval and merge

What enters authority—and what remains outside this package

Merging does

Accept P-STD-009's Initiative + Feature SID taxonomy, Feature lifecycle/resolver, EG-<slug> grouping, explicit targeting, lineage, and legacy freeze.
Land coordinated P-STD-002/004/005/008 and Program WDL alignment plus Program SPS discovery/resolver interfaces.
Accept the TK004 census boundary: 17 Epic-root families plus separately frozen Feature-root residue T102A1.
Accept R-001–R-007 as explicit owner-bound residue—not as completed receiving work.
Authorize maintainer merge of the exact package only after the explicit HDO act; merge hash then anchors the #449 acceptance ledger.

Intentionally does not

Mutate PM board schema/options or T106 tooling/helpers; R-006 remains conditional and untriggered.
Migrate or rename per-Initiative legacy identities, paths, owners, registries, plans, or files.
Revive Story as an SID-bearing workscope tier; Request/Design Story assumptions remain owner-routed legacy reconciliation.
Edit AC004-owned SPS/guidance/templates, Request/Design templates, scaffold/validator/tests, or the tools catalog.
Complete R-001–R-007, close #449/#481–#484, or make P-STD-009 authoritative before HDO recorded act + merge + merge-hash-bound #449 ledger.

Decision-complete confirmation

Recycle-gap closure and cycle-1 package integrity

Tick a claim only after inspecting its pinned evidence. Every file link is SHA-pinned so it survives branch deletion; every repo file also carries a copy control for local or IDE navigation.

Working through the matrix0 / 24 confirmed

A Recycle-gap closure · prior conditions and controlled remediation

The original mechanical conditions remain traceable; TK005 then closes the HDO's cycle-0 registry, placement, authority and metadata gaps without reopening CHECK001.

M-01C1 · normative references

P-STD-002, P-STD-004, P-STD-005, and P-STD-008 each contain a resolving P-STD-009 Normative References row, with matching changelog entries.

319c8563P-STD-002 · referencesP-STD-008 · references

How to verify

Open the closure commit; confirm one P-STD-009 row in all four standards and corresponding changelog-only traces. The delta must not change CHECK000 architecture.

M-02Recycle gap · register_ removal

P-STD-004 removes the premature generic register_ normalization introduced only for the activity-scoped TK004 register; prd_ remains registered.

4a1fdce2P-STD-004 · current registry

How to verify

Search current normative rows for register_: no generic live rule remains. Historical/changelog mentions remain truthful.

M-03C3 · exact group grammar

P-STD-009's EG-<slug> production now enforces exactly 2–40 characters; EG-x is rejected without cross-reading prose.

319c8563P-STD-009 · CLAUSE-005A

How to verify

Confirm the production is [a-z0-9][a-z0-9-]{0,38}[a-z0-9]; inspect the standard changelog for the condition-closure trace.

M-04C4 · legacy annotations

P-STD-005 marks every affected E/S token-table scope as legacy-only, and P-STD-004 marks the Epic research row legacy-only and non-authorizing.

319c8563P-STD-005 · CLAUSE-002BP-STD-004 · CLAUSE-007B

How to verify

Read each clause standalone. Neither may authorize new Epic/Story-scoped identity minting or new Epic research placement.

B Package integrity, assurance limit, and gate proof

Eleven claims about the reviewed package and the exact decision boundary. Row M-14 is an explicit assurance-limit acceptance—not hidden assurance.

M-05Reviewer authorship · immutable REVIEW

Fable directly authored the sole canonical REVIEW in fresh session 481981e0-e0d2-4b95-9819-95485872caae, against frozen head b0a66af3…; the Developer committed it unchanged at 2174e390….

2174e390Fable REVIEW · v1.0.0

How to verify

Confirm frontmatter author/model/session/head and §II direct-write boundary. Compare the blob at the REVIEW commit with the package version; later closure must not amend REVIEW prose.

M-06#481–#484 · 29 criteria

All 29 task acceptance checkboxes were reviewed against live #481–#484 contracts: 26 MET, 3 MET-C, no scope bleed, no hidden deferral, and no Situation B finding.

2174e390REVIEW · §VI–IX#481 #482 #483 #484

How to verify

Use the REVIEW's acceptance-criteria matrix and Round Changelog. Confirm seven TK001, seven TK002, seven TK003, and eight TK004 criteria = 29 total.

M-07P-STD-009 doctrine

The draft standard faithfully encodes the accepted two-axis doctrine without reviving Initiative-only SID, Epic SID, Story SID, or Feature-root execution models.

0fd6c1ffP-STD-009 · v0.1.1

How to verify

Inspect CLAUSE-001–010 and ADR-001: Feature minting/lifecycle, Initiative-owned registry, Epic metadata, explicit UID targets, lineage, legacy freeze, and extension boundaries.

M-08Standards + WDL integrity

P-STD-002/004/005/008 and Program WDL consistently separate Feature lifecycle from status, use Initiative-owned placement, preserve frozen grammar, and target workscope without Feature-root Timeline UIDs.

2fb737f4P-STD-005 · current packageProgram WDL · v1.4.0

How to verify

Trace P-STD-002-CLAUSE-058, P-STD-004-CLAUSE-005/006, P-STD-005-CLAUSE-008A/008L, P-STD-008-CLAUSE-007D, and WDL execution-target guidance.

M-09Program SPS placement

Canonical sps_P.md owns the Program workscope registry: Section C is the link-first Initiative/Feature resolver and Section D owns workscope vocabulary, with the progressive-disclosure variance disclosed pending AC004 reconstruction.

4a1fdce2sps_P.md · §§C–D

How to verify

Confirm sps_P.md is the sole current canonical SPS path, Section C holds registry/breakdown, Section D holds terms, and no live resolver points into AC008/internal.

M-10Census + family freeze

The gate-relevant census is honestly bounded: 52 historical observations → 47 reproducible exact tokens → 18 non-Initiative roots → 17 Epic-root families plus separately frozen T102A1; upstream source limits remain disclosed.

94557ee8TK004 register · §§II–III

How to verify

Run the two frozen-baseline commands in register §II. Confirm all 17 Epic-root rows and the separate Feature-root row include owner, disposition, resolution, and evidence.

M-11Route integrity

R-001–R-007 each name an owner, affected surface, acceptance condition, disposition, and evidence; open/orphan/conditional/deferred routes remain visible and are not represented as completed.

TK004 register · §V

How to verify

Compare every row in §V with §4 below. R-002/R-003 must remain orphan-visible; R-006 conditional/untriggered; R-007 one deferred bundle.

M-12Merge semantics

The HDO accepts exactly the §2 boundary: standards/SPS/freeze routes enter the package; no board/T106 mutation, per-Initiative migration, Story revival, excluded owner edit, route completion, or premature authority is implied.

GATE001 evidence · §§I/VIActivity plan · GATE001

How to verify

Read evidence package posture/open routes and plan gate entry/exit criteria. Confirm authority begins only after recorded act, merge, and #449 ledger.

M-13Developer validation

Developer validation is green: diff/structure/reference checks, census/route checks, ancestry/scope checks, and governed pytest all passed; closure rerun reports 95 passed / 3 skipped.

Cycle-00 evidence · §IV/VI

How to verify

Confirm the governed runner result and exact closure assertions. This row records Developer-attested validation; independent-review limits are separately accepted in M-14.

M-14⚠ Historical CHECK001 assurance limit

I acknowledge that GitHub has no configured checks for PR #486 and the CHECK001 Fable Reviewer could not independently run governed pytest within its tool-approval boundary. At that historical frozen head the reviewed implementation delta was Markdown-only; Developer pytest passed 95 / 3 skipped. This is bounded mitigation, not independent runtime assurance for the later TK005 package.

REVIEW · §V / F6Developer evidence · §IV

How to verify

Inspect the historical CHECK001 head and exact runner limitation. Do not extend that Markdown-only statement to TK005, which later added a Python census reporter.

M-15Gate proof + authority

Gate proof is complete through TK005 acceptance, Fable full-package review, Consultant disposition, HDO-authorized condition closure, and final hosted QA verification. The HDO act, merge, ledger and closeout remain pending; P-STD-009 is not yet effective authority.

ff4fdc3fFable review + Consultant disposition

How to verify

Confirm the review exchange, exact condition-closure delta, final staging hashes and PR cycle-1 body. Confirm no HDO act, merge, ledger or closeout has occurred.

M-16D3 · EG-<slug>

HDO D3 is encoded as a stable mnemonic EG-<slug> key with a separately mutable display name; rename preserves the key, retirement is replacement-only with successor history, and legacy Epic tokens are aliases only—not current group keys.

4a1fdce2P-STD-009 · D3 semantics

How to verify

Read the group-key grammar, rename, retirement/successor and legacy-alias rules together; confirm no legacy token can be minted as a current group key.

M-17Conditional accepted metadata

P-STD-009 and the Program STD index express one coherent conditional promotion: accepted becomes effective only after the future exact-package HDO approval, PR #486 merge, and merge-hash-bound #449 ledger—not from this candidate, the completed Fable review, or condition closure.

4a1fdce2P-STD-009 · metadata

How to verify

Check status/effective/approval fields and Program index wording. No field may imply present authority while PR #486 remains open.

M-18COMM + AC004 boundary

COMM c8 is indexed under CBI #393 with carrier #499, while AC004/#190/#458/#459 and AC009/#450 remain receiving routes. AC008 makes no semantic edit to AC004-owned SPS guidance, templates, or files.

4a1fdce2TK005 evidence · COMM

How to verify

Confirm #393 → #499 final relationship, #499 off-board state, receiving links, and the repository zero-touch assertion for AC004-owned surfaces.

M-19Execution-incident recovery

The duplicate-executor collision and COMM c8 relationship inversion are disclosed with adopted/corrected/rejected provenance. History was preserved, the relationship was atomically corrected, and the independent task reviewer found both recoveries non-blocking.

4a1fdce2TK005 REVIEW · incidents

How to verify

Read REVIEW §IV and the accumulating EVIDENCE incident record; confirm no history rewrite or cross-owner repository mutation hid the recovery.

M-20Evidence + provenance

The cycle-1 package carries complete acceptance-criterion traceability, migration and rollback evidence, reference census, incident record, tests, immutable baseline/candidate SHAs, reviewer identity, write boundary, and Consultant acceptance.

4a1fdce2Accumulating EVIDENCE

How to verify

Trace every TK005 criterion to an evidence section and the zero-finding REVIEW. Confirm starting/final SHAs and producer attribution are explicit.

M-21⚠ TK005 review assurance variance

I acknowledge that the TK005 Reviewer did not rerun governed pytest and inaccurately described the candidate as repository-text-only: TK005 added the read-only Python census reporter. The Reviewer did inspect and reproduce its census outputs, while the Developer and Consultant each ran governed pytest at 95 / 3 skipped. Fable must independently assess this disclosed variance; the prior PASS is not represented as independent runtime assurance.

4a1fdce2TK005 REVIEW · §IIIcensus reporter · Python

How to verify

Compare REVIEW §III with the base-to-head file list and the reporter commit. Confirm the Fable packet is required to assess this variance and that no one claims the task Reviewer independently ran pytest.

M-22Fable gate review · conditions closed

Fable 5/high reviewed exact head 590d344e… in session 1b66f8d6… and returned ACCEPT WITH CONDITIONS: six findings, one material. The HDO authorized one bounded closure pass; COND-1/COND-2 and approved F-03/F-04 truthfulness corrections are closed without reopening CHECK001 or running a second review.

ff4fdc3fFable raw review

How to verify

Read the raw verdict and Consultant disposition, then compare the reviewed-to-final delta: PR-body replacement, meter 15→24, evidence grammar wording, SPS illustrative label, result/evidence integration and hosted QA proof only.

M-23HDO recorded-act semantics

Only an unambiguous durable HDO disposition for this same GATE001 on PR #486 and/or #449 is the gate act. A merge disposition authorizes the exact reviewed package; the later merge event and #449 merge-hash ledger complete acceptance proof.

Plan · recorded act

How to verify

Confirm checkbox state, decision-card selection, copied text, Fable review and HTML staging are all non-authoritative aids.

M-24Cycle-1 hosted identity

The prior cycle-0 QA bytes, staging URL and hash are superseded. This final cycle-1 HTML was redeployed after Fable result integration and condition closure; consolidated evidence records matching source, staged and served hashes. Any later byte change requires another deployment and hash record.

ff4fdc3fGATE001 evidence

How to verify

Compare the final stable staging URL, source/staged/served hashes, noindex headers, one-document request and desktop/mobile Playwright record in consolidated evidence.

Owner-bound residue

Seven routes remain explicit after acceptance

Program SPS is the live workscope resolver; the TK004 register is retained only as historical census/freeze and route evidence. Every row below states its disposition, and receiving owners retain authority.

Routed open

R-001 · T102-PH001-AC004 owner

At AC004 CHECK001, consume accepted FSID registry, grouping, targeting, and legacy resolver interfaces. AC008 edits no AC004-owned surface.

Orphan visible

R-002 · T102B Request domain owner

Receiving activity not yet selected. Remove new Story-SID minting, use Task UIDs, preserve historical Story resolution.

Orphan visible

R-003 · T102D Design domain owner

Receiving activity not yet selected. Remove new Story-SID minting in Design templates/logs while retaining historical links.

Routed open

R-004 · P-PH000-AC009 / #450

Consume the accepted taxonomy in P-STD-001 reconstruction and Concept reconciliation without rewriting AC008 lineage.

Per owner

R-005 · each Initiative owner

On next governed touch, preserve frozen IDs, stop legacy minting, and add resolver/lineage evidence where a material change occurs; no bulk migration.

Conditional

R-006 · T106 owner

Not triggered. If board-visible compatibility becomes necessary, T106 owns schema/helper approval, rollback/export evidence, and option-ID preservation.

Deferred bundle

R-007 · future tooling owner

After acceptance and owner authorization, implement scaffold, validator, regression tests, and tools catalog together—never a partial script-only change.

TK004 historical route evidence

Recorded-act semantics

Choose a working disposition, then record it durably

The exact durable act: post an unambiguous GATE001 disposition on PR #486 and/or #449. For merge, bind approval to this exact package and preserve the acknowledged M-14 and M-21 assurance limits. After merge, record the merge hash and acceptance mapping on #449.

Non-authoritative state: completing the matrix, selecting a card, or copying the generated record does not perform that act. inspect is intentionally not a gate disposition.

Incomplete: confirm all claims and select a working disposition.

Optional rationale / required blocking reason for hold or recycle

Provenance & self-conformance

This artifact

Current state: final cycle-1 HDO candidate after Fable review and authorized condition closure; HDO disposition remains pending.
Reviewed package: 590d344e9fca7a8e48491d3d4b79e0e333538ef9
Review record: ff4fdc3f1f77c3e9030656ef25f20db0307eca1c
Staging identity: final stable URL and source/staged/served hashes live in consolidated evidence; this page does not self-attest hosted-byte identity.
Construction: one self-contained HTML file · strict CSP · noindex/nofollow · zero external runtime resources

Conformance statement

This surface follows the P-STD-008 package-shaped gate grammar: journey and prior assurance (§1); precise merge effects/exclusions (§2); traceable claims with HDO confirmations (§3); explicit residue/owners/dispositions (§4); and durable recorded-act semantics (§5). Its interactive state is deliberately non-authoritative.